OneWorld Health
A small
San Francisco
charity has big
plans for bringing new drugs to the world
Dr. Victoria Hale's professional story started as
former Genentech executive and Food and Drug
Administration official. But her personal story started years ago when close
friends had a 13-year-old daughter diagnosed with a deadly form of cancer.
Doctors had little to offer them, so Hale began her search. Hale found hope, two
of them in fact.
IMS Health estimates that the global pharmaceutical market in
2006 exceeded $260 billion dollars. We read about blockbuster drugs every day
that are impacting cancer, AIDS/HIV and aging. New compounds are being
discovered daily and exploration continues from the Amazon forest to the depths
of the ocean. It would seem on the surface that this powerful economic
juggernaut is poised to steamroll diseases across the globe.
Dr. Victoria Hale discovered that this was sadly far from the
truth. Dr. Hale had already put in a stint at Genentech, but had left in 1995 to
start her own regulatory consulting business. While she was consulting she
visited the World Health Organization in
Switzerland.
There she discovered a disturbing truth: in reality there are drugs and
compounds all across the world that have been shelved at
some point in the research and
development process. No one, it
seemed, was working to develop these compounds
into drugs. It was shocking. Dr. Hale discovered the
same situation happening to dozens, perhaps
even hundreds, of potential drugs too expensive to develop for rare conditions
or for diseases typically affecting the poorest of the poor.
The repercussions are staggering. Worldwide, it is estimated that
two million children under five years of age die from diarrhea annually, and
that every 30 seconds an African child dies from malaria. Viseral leishmaniasis
(VL), also known as black fever, afflicts 1.5 million people worldwide, killing
some 500,000 people every year, according to
the World Health Organization. Yet, the Western world remains largely unaware of
the disease.
Dr. Hale saw the fatal affliction first hand in 2000. After her
meeting with the World Health Organization she
traveled to
India to visit a
doctor working on VL and witnessed the impact this curable disease had on poor,
rural villages in
India. On a
global scale Dr. Hale could immediately see the
problem. Although developing countries represent 80 percent of the world's
population, they are responsible for only 20 percent of
medicine sales. And the number of drugs that
were being developed for use in the Third
World paled in
comparison to the number of medicines developed
to combat cancer, cardiovascular disease or AIDS. Now, acutely aware of the
number of neglected compounds with medicinal
potential, Hale wanted to find a way to guide these would-be
medicines into
development, creating new life-saving drugs.
She also wanted to tackle diseases that disproportionately affect the world's
poor. So six years ago she and her husband, Dr. Ahvie Herskowitz of the
University of
California, San
Francisco, founded OneWorld Health.
Hale and Herskowitz put up a total of $100,000 of their own
money and signed a promissory note for $315,000. They used the ground floor of
their house as offices. Both worked without pay for two years, overcoming
numerous obstacles. The I.R.S. turned down
Hale's request for nonprofit status three times
in 10 months, suspicious that the couple's plan was a
scheme to shelter pharmaceutical profits. Two
weeks after convincing the I.R.S. that OneWorld Health was indeed a nonprofit
organization in a profit dominated industry, Hale and Herskowitz set out to
tackle black fever.
Black fever, known locally in
India as kala
azar, is a parasitic infection caused by tiny, biting sand flies. It can be
fatal if left untreated, and has stretched from
India to
Nepal and
Bangladesh and
as far as
Brazil. If the
half million deaths caused each year by the disease occurred in
America, black fever would rank third, behind
heart disease and cancer, as a leading cause of death in the United States.
Instead, black fever is a neglected disease. In the 1960s
development of a promising drug called
Paromomycin was all but abandoned for lack of profit potential. Paromomycin was
left sitting on a corporate shelf somewhere in
the United
States. Hale was determined to dust off that
shelf. As a result of nearly three decades of company
mergers and neglect, "ownership" of Paromomycin
had fallen into the hands of the World Health Organization (W.H.O.), despite the
fact that the W.H.O. lacked the funding to develop the drug or conduct clinical
trials. For two years, negotiations with W.H.O. to secure the necessary
permission to allow OneWorld Health to develop paromomycin dragged on.
To understand the task in front of Dr. Hale, it is necessary to
understand the process that billion dollar pharmaceutical companies endure to
bring new drugs to market. OneWorld was tackling a production cycle with a
fraction of the funding and with compounds that had been shelved for years. The
development process for new drugs consists of
three distinct stages: 1) Research, which includes laboratory research and
screening to identify positive leads; 2)
Development, which includes optimizing a drug
and guiding it through clinical trials and regulatory approval; and 3)
Production, which includes finding manufacturing and distribution partners.
It is a process that takes years and often several attempts at
securing regulatory approval. To its advantage, OneWorld was working with
compounds previously discovered and as such, was skipping most of the research
stage. But they still had to work through the trials and approval processes. For
instance, it took three years to get Paromomycin into Phase 4 Clinical Trials in
India.
Next the manufacturing and distribution problems had to be
resolved. Since OneWorld Health was not developing global drugs with a large
audience, their ability to create a cost-effective network of local distributors
could have been the piece that made or broke their model. Distribution typically
has the added headache of working with
government health ministries and
non-government health organizations. All to
distribute drugs Hale hoped to sell for pennies per dose. These challenges would
vex even the largest pharmaceutical companies, but OneWorld Health was
attempting to do this with only a fraction of the resources.
However, funding did appear. Hale's efforts and tenacity
attracted the attention of-and substantial funding from-the Bill and Melinda
Gates Foundation. Eventually, OneWorld Health secured approval of their VL drug
from India's
government. On the distribution front, OneWorld
Health has given the license to Gland Pharma, an Indian drug company that has
agreed to manufacture and sell the drug at cost, estimated to be approximately
$10.00 (U.S.)
per treatment for each infected person. Hale
continues to work with the Indian government to
secure final approval to distribute the drug to remote villages at the end of
pothole-pocketed roads. OneWorld will not gain any
income from the drug.
On the heels of Hale's groundbreaking success, pharmaceutical
researchers are offering OneWorld Health a variety of compounds for
consideration and possible developme
nt.
Equally impressive, many of these researchers are
volunteering their ti
me to help Hale in her
efforts. At the end of the day, Hale does not
bla
me profit-driven drug manufacturers.
Instead, she tries to work with them. She acknowledges that many in the
pharmaceutical industry are in the business to ease suffering and save lives,
but she understands that shareholders demand profits. It is almost certain that
Hale's efforts will save millions of lives, and hopes are high that OneWorld
Health's new efforts to tackle malaria and chronic diarrhea in children will be
just as successful. But Hale's greatest legacy may be the creation of what many
believed to be an oxymoron, a "nonprofit drug
company."